Um, OK, obligatory disclaimer here: I am a huge Porcupine Tree fan. My first exposure was In Absentia, quickly followed by their back-catalog, and then Deadwing, which we saw live at the HOB last year. They, as much as any other recent band, rekindled my interest in prog (in the sense of progressive music, not in the made-from-a-kit nu-prog vein).
That said, I have to run against the grain of apparently every critic on the Interweb, and state that Fear of a Blank Planet – their latest release – does absolutely nothing for me. I’ve listened to it 6 or 8 times in the last two weeks, and saw them live this past Friday, and it’s just not grabbing me by the ear like I’ve come to expect. If anything, it comes across as forced and passionless. I understand this is an album with a specific message, one of alienation, isolation, consumerism, etc., but that’s no excuse for the writing, playing, and production to be completely bloodless.
I had high hopes for the concert, thinking “Maybe it’ll come through live.” Nope. Sorry, Steven – I love your work, but I’m not feeling the love for this one. To be fair, there are some good components, the polyrhythmic Opeth-y bits are present (again!?), RB’s keyboards are lush and dramatic – maybe even moreso than the last two albums, but there’s just no “Wow!” here for me.
Granted, you can’t please everyone, and there are certainly plenty of folks who hold this album in high regard. That’s cool. Me, I’ll be the guy listening to Lightbulb Sun while I wait for their next release.